In professional wrestling, few creative decisions generate as much debate as choosing when a top star should finally win the championship. For Cody Rhodes, that moment came with enormous risk.
After returning to WWE in 2022 as the reinvigorated “American Nightmare,” Rhodes quickly became one of the company’s most popular performers. His mission was simple yet deeply personal: capture the WWE Championship that had eluded the legendary Rhodes family for generations.
However, WWE shocked the wrestling world at WrestleMania 39 when Roman Reigns defeated Rhodes to extend his historic title reign.
Now, more than three years later, Cody has revealed that he privately questioned whether WWE’s controversial booking decision would pay off.
Speaking on his What Do You Wanna Talk About? podcast alongside WWE Hall of Famer Diamond Dallas Page (DDP), Rhodes admitted he worried about losing the momentum he had spent years building outside WWE.
Why Cody Rhodes Feared Losing at WrestleMania 39
Before returning to WWE, Rhodes spent six years reinventing himself across multiple promotions, transforming from a talented mid-card performer into one of wrestling’s biggest attractions.
His surprise comeback at WrestleMania 38 generated an emotional response from fans, and victories over Seth Rollins immediately established him as a top-tier star.
Winning the 2023 Royal Rumble further cemented his status as the leading challenger to Roman Reigns.
For many fans, WrestleMania 39 felt like the perfect ending to the “Finish the Story” narrative.
Instead, WWE chose a different path.
During the podcast, Rhodes recalled a conversation with Diamond Dallas Page before the event.
“You asked me the question I didn’t want to answer. You said, ‘What happens if you lose?'”
DDP believed the audience’s emotional investment in Cody would only grow stronger after a setback.
“Does it really matter if you do the job this time? The fans will want it even more.”
Despite the reassurance, Rhodes admitted he remained uncertain.
“That’s crazy gambling.”
The concern was understandable. Wrestling history is filled with examples of performers losing momentum after suffering major defeats at critical moments.
Why WWE’s Risky Booking Decision Worked
At the time, many fans criticized WWE’s decision to keep the championship on Roman Reigns.
Social media erupted with frustration, while analysts questioned whether the company had missed the ideal opportunity to crown its next long-term face of the company.
Yet WWE’s creative team, led by Triple H, remained committed to extending the story.
Instead of weakening Rhodes, the loss deepened his connection with fans.
His journey shifted from a straightforward championship pursuit to a story about resilience, perseverance, and redemption.
By the time WrestleMania XL arrived, fan support for Rhodes had reached unprecedented levels.
| Key Moment | Impact on Cody Rhodes’ Story |
|---|---|
| WrestleMania 38 return | Reintroduced Rhodes as a top star |
| 2023 Royal Rumble victory | Established him as Roman Reigns’ challenger |
| WrestleMania 39 defeat | Created emotional investment and adversity |
| WrestleMania XL victory | Delivered a historic payoff to “Finish the Story” |
| Subsequent title reigns | Solidified Rhodes as WWE’s franchise star |
How “Finish the Story” Became WWE’s Most Successful Long-Term Narrative
Modern wrestling audiences often demand immediate payoffs, making long-term storytelling increasingly difficult.
However, WWE’s decision to delay Cody Rhodes’ championship victory demonstrated the value of patience when executed effectively.
The company transformed a potentially damaging loss into a defining chapter of Rhodes’ career.
His eventual triumph at WrestleMania XL over Roman Reigns became more meaningful because fans experienced the disappointment, uncertainty, and anticipation alongside him.
The emotional investment created by that journey elevated the moment beyond a standard title change.
It became a cultural moment within professional wrestling.
What Cody Rhodes’ Story Reveals About WWE’s Current Creative Philosophy
Under Triple H’s leadership, WWE has increasingly emphasized layered storytelling instead of short-term surprises.
Rather than focusing solely on immediate reactions, the creative team has prioritized narratives that unfold over months or even years.
Cody Rhodes’ championship journey reflects this philosophy perfectly.
- Character growth matters as much as championship victories.
- Setbacks can strengthen fan investment when used effectively.
- Long-term storytelling creates more memorable moments.
- Emotional connection often outweighs instant gratification.
The success of Rhodes’ storyline may influence how WWE approaches future main-event programs.
Cody Rhodes Reveals a Unique Clause in His WWE Contract
During the same podcast episode, Rhodes shared another fascinating detail about his current WWE deal.
Rather than negotiating personal perks, the WWE Champion included a clause designed to benefit wrestling legends.
The provision allows Rhodes to select a WWE Hall of Famer or industry veteran to appear alongside him in television commercials connected to his brand partnerships.
According to Rhodes, the decision reflects his desire to give back to the wrestling community that helped shape his career.
It’s a rare example of a top star using contractual leverage to create opportunities for others rather than focusing exclusively on personal gain.
Why Cody Rhodes Has Become WWE’s Modern Standard-Bearer
Rhodes’ willingness to discuss his doubts openly has become one of his greatest strengths.
In an industry built on larger-than-life personas, authenticity has helped him connect with audiences on a deeper level.
His journey—from leaving WWE to reinventing himself and ultimately returning to achieve his family’s dream—resonates because it feels genuine.
That authenticity has made him one of the most relatable top stars of the modern era.
More importantly, it has proven that vulnerability and perseverance can be just as compelling as dominance.
Conclusion
When Cody Rhodes lost to Roman Reigns at WrestleMania 39, many believed WWE had made a costly mistake.
Even Rhodes himself questioned whether the gamble was worth taking.
However, what initially seemed like a controversial booking decision ultimately became the foundation of one of wrestling’s most memorable success stories.
By trusting the process and embracing adversity, Rhodes transformed defeat into the defining chapter of his career.
His story serves as a reminder that in professional wrestling, the most powerful moments are not always about winning immediately—they’re about making the audience believe the journey was worth the wait.
For breaking news and live news updates, like us on Facebook or follow us on Twitter and Instagram. Read more on Latest Sports on thefoxdaily.com.
COMMENTS 0