
Disappointing returns after five years of investing through a systematic investment plan (SIP) can make investors question whether they should continue, switch Mutual Funds or withdraw their money. However, a slow start does not necessarily indicate that an investment will deliver poor long-term results.
A November 2026 study by WhiteOak Capital Mutual Fund suggests that SIPs with annualised returns of 8% or less during their first five years historically delivered higher average returns over a 10-year period than SIPs that started with stronger performance.
The findings highlight the importance of investment duration, market cycles and disciplined investing. They also suggest that investors should examine a fund’s performance against its benchmark and category peers before making decisions based on short-term returns.
Can a Slow-Starting SIP Deliver Better 10-Year Returns?
According to WhiteOak Capital Mutual Fund’s historical analysis, SIPs that generated annualised returns of 8% or less during their first five years recorded an average annualised return of 18.30% over the full 10-year period.
In comparison, SIPs that delivered more than 8% annualised returns during their first five years recorded a lower average 10-year return of 14.60%.
The analysis used the BSE Sensex Total Return Index (TRI), covering the period from August 1996 to October 2026. The results indicate that a relatively weak beginning did not necessarily prevent an SIP from delivering stronger returns over a longer investment horizon.
One possible explanation is the way SIPs work during market fluctuations. Investors contribute a fixed amount at regular intervals, purchasing more units when prices are lower and fewer units when prices are higher.
When markets decline during the early years of an investment, regular contributions can accumulate additional units at relatively lower prices. If markets recover later, those accumulated units may contribute to stronger long-term returns.
However, the historical difference between the two groups should not be interpreted as proof that poorly performing SIPs will always outperform. The figures represent historical index-based averages, and actual mutual fund returns can vary considerably.
What the WhiteOak Study Reveals About 5-Year and 10-Year SIP Returns
The study highlights an important difference between evaluating an investment over five years and assessing its performance over a decade. A five-year period may capture only one part of a market cycle, while a longer period can include both declines and recoveries.
The historical averages reported in the analysis were:
- Slow-starting SIPs: Investments earning 8% or less annually during the first five years recorded an average 10-year annualised return of 18.30%.
- Stronger-starting SIPs: Investments earning more than 8% annually during the first five years recorded an average 10-year annualised return of 14.60%.
- Difference: The slow-starting group delivered an average return 3.70 percentage points higher over the full 10-year period.
- Data period: The analysis covered historical Sensex TRI performance from August 1996 to October 2026.
These findings suggest that the timing of market movements can influence SIP outcomes. An investment that begins during a difficult market phase may benefit from accumulating units at lower valuations, while one that starts during a strong market phase may initially purchase units at higher prices.
Nevertheless, the result depends on the subsequent market performance. If markets do not recover or remain weak for an extended period, the benefit of accumulating units at lower prices may not be sufficient to generate satisfactory returns.
Why SIP Investments Can Benefit From Market Corrections
One of the main advantages of an SIP is that investors do not need to invest their entire amount at a single market level. Instead, they spread their contributions over time, which can reduce the risk of committing all their money immediately before a market decline.
This approach is commonly associated with rupee-cost averaging. When the net asset value (NAV) of a mutual fund falls, a fixed SIP instalment purchases more units. When the NAV rises, the same instalment purchases fewer units.
For example, an investor contributing Rs 5,000 every month will accumulate more mutual fund units when the NAV is Rs 25 than when it is Rs 50. If the investment eventually benefits from a market recovery, the additional units purchased during the lower-price period can improve the overall outcome.
However, rupee-cost averaging does not guarantee profits or protect investors from market losses. It changes the way units are accumulated but cannot eliminate the risks associated with the underlying assets.
The strategy is generally more useful when investors maintain discipline and continue investing through different market conditions rather than attempting to predict every market movement.
Is Five Years Enough to Judge an SIP?
Five years can provide useful information about a mutual fund’s performance, but it may not always be enough to judge its long-term suitability. Equity markets move through different phases, and a five-year investment period can sometimes coincide with an unfavourable market cycle.
The WhiteOak study also examined how the probability of negative returns changed as the investment horizon increased.
According to the analysis, approximately 92% of the five-year SIP periods examined generated positive returns. The proportion increased to 100% for the eight-year and 10-year periods covered by the historical data.
This suggests that longer investment horizons historically reduced the likelihood of negative returns in the Sensex TRI analysis. However, it is important to understand what these figures actually represent.
The results are based on historical index performance rather than the returns of individual mutual fund schemes. A specific fund may perform differently because of its investment strategy, portfolio composition, expenses and fund management decisions.
Positive Returns Do Not Always Mean Satisfactory Returns
Although the study found that all the eight-year and 10-year periods examined delivered positive returns, positive performance does not automatically mean that investors achieved their financial objectives.
The worst historical annualised return for the eight-year periods was 3.03%, according to the analysis. Such a return could be insufficient to meet an investor’s expectations, particularly when inflation is considered.
For example, if an investment grows at 3.03% annually while the cost of living increases at a higher rate, the investor’s purchasing power may decline despite receiving a positive nominal return.
This distinction is important when planning for long-term financial goals such as retirement, children’s education or purchasing a home. Investors should assess whether their portfolio is generating returns that are appropriate for their required time horizon and risk tolerance.
Therefore, the objective should not simply be to avoid negative returns. Investors also need to consider inflation-adjusted returns and whether their investments are progressing towards their financial targets.
Should You Continue or Switch Your SIP?
The decision to continue or switch an SIP should depend on why the investment has underperformed. Disappointing returns over five years may reflect broader market weakness rather than problems with the mutual fund itself.
If the overall market has struggled and the fund has performed reasonably compared with its benchmark and category peers, weak absolute returns alone may not justify stopping the investment.
However, persistent underperformance against relevant benchmarks and comparable schemes across different market conditions may indicate that the fund requires closer examination.
Investors should consider several factors before making a decision:
- Benchmark performance: Compare the fund’s returns with its appropriate benchmark over multiple periods rather than relying on a single five-year figure.
- Category comparison: Check whether the fund has consistently lagged behind comparable mutual fund schemes.
- Investment strategy: Review whether the fund’s investment approach or portfolio composition has changed significantly.
- Risk profile: Examine whether the level of risk remains appropriate for your financial circumstances and investment horizon.
- Financial goals: Consider whether the fund continues to support your objectives and expected investment timeline.
Switching to a fund simply because it has recently delivered higher returns can be risky. A recent top performer may have benefited from a temporary market trend that does not necessarily continue.
Stopping an SIP Is Not the Same as Withdrawing Your Investment
Investors should understand the difference between discontinuing future SIP contributions and redeeming their existing mutual fund units. These are separate decisions and can have different financial consequences.
Stopping an SIP generally means that future monthly instalments will no longer be deducted from the investor’s bank account. The units already accumulated in the mutual fund can remain invested unless the investor chooses to redeem them.
Investors may also decide to redirect future contributions to another mutual fund while retaining their existing units in the original scheme. This approach can provide flexibility when reviewing an investment portfolio.
However, redeeming existing investments or switching units from one scheme to another may trigger capital gains tax and applicable exit loads. The tax treatment depends on the type of mutual fund, holding period and applicable regulations.
Before making a switch, investors should therefore calculate the potential tax liability and other charges. A decision based only on recent performance could result in unnecessary costs.
Common SIP Mistakes Investors Should Avoid
Investors sometimes make decisions based on short-term market movements or comparisons with funds that have recently performed well. Such behaviour can undermine a long-term investment strategy.
Some common mistakes include:
- Stopping during market declines: Discontinuing contributions during a correction may prevent investors from accumulating additional units at lower prices.
- Chasing recent winners: Moving money into a fund solely because of its recent performance may expose investors to the risk of buying after a strong market rally.
- Ignoring benchmark returns: Looking only at absolute returns can make it difficult to identify whether underperformance is caused by the market or the fund itself.
- Overlooking inflation: Positive nominal returns may still fail to preserve purchasing power over long periods.
- Ignoring investment goals: Continuing an unsuitable fund simply because it has been held for several years may not support the investor’s financial objectives.
A disciplined review process can help investors avoid emotional decisions and focus on the factors that matter for long-term financial planning.
What Investors Should Take Away From the 5-Year vs 10-Year SIP Study
The WhiteOak Capital Mutual Fund analysis highlights why a disappointing five-year SIP performance should not automatically be treated as a failure. Historically, the group of investments with weaker first-five-year returns recorded a higher average return over the full 10-year period than the group with stronger initial performance.
The findings also show that longer investment horizons were associated with a lower frequency of negative returns in the historical Sensex TRI data. However, the results do not guarantee similar outcomes for individual mutual fund schemes or future market conditions.
For investors, the most important step is to understand the reason behind underperformance. A fund that remains fundamentally suitable and performs reasonably against its benchmark may deserve continued consideration. A scheme that consistently underperforms comparable investments or no longer matches the investor’s goals may require a review.
Ultimately, five years of disappointing SIP returns should prompt a careful assessment rather than an automatic exit. The decision should depend on the fund’s quality, risk profile, investment strategy and suitability for long-term financial goals not simply on whether its recent returns look attractive.
Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and should not be considered investment advice. Historical returns do not guarantee future performance. Mutual fund investments are subject to market risks. Investors should consult a certified financial adviser before making investment decisions.
For breaking news and live news updates, like us on Facebook or follow us on Twitter and Instagram. Read more on Latest Business on thefoxdaily.com.

COMMENTS 0