Kapil Dev Questions Mohammed Shami’s Decision to Retire From Tests

Kapil Dev questions Mohammed Shami's Test retirement, arguing the Indian pacer should have waited and kept the possibility of an international comeback open.

Published: 4 hours ago

By Ankit kumar

Kapil Dev Questions Mohammed Shami's Decision to Retire From Tests
Kapil Dev Questions Mohammed Shami’s Decision to Retire From Tests

Former India captain Kapil Dev has questioned Mohammed Shami’s decision to retire from Test cricket, suggesting that the experienced fast bowler should have waited before bringing his red-ball career to an end. Shami announced his retirement on November 6, closing a chapter in which he collected 229 wickets in 64 Test matches for India.

Kapil believes Shami could have kept the possibility of an international comeback open by continuing to play. The former captain pointed to the opportunities that can emerge even after long periods away from the national team, arguing that retirement removes a player’s chance of being considered for selection.

Kapil Dev questions Mohammed Shami’s Test retirement

Shami finished his Test career with an impressive record of 229 wickets at an average of 27.71. He registered six five-wicket hauls, with his best bowling figures standing at 6/56. Despite his achievements, the fast bowler had not represented India in any format for more than a year, with his last Test appearance coming in 2023.

Speaking to Mid-Day, Kapil expressed his disappointment over Shami’s decision and suggested that the pacer could have continued working towards a return to international cricket.

“He shouldn’t have retired from Test cricket. He should have waited. Where Shami is concerned, you just have to work hard. If you can get two more years of Test cricket, why not? This opportunity will never come back. They can’t pick you if you retire, but if you are playing, you still have an option,” said Kapil Dev on the Mid-Day.

Kapil’s comments focused on the importance of remaining available for selection rather than assuming that a period outside the national setup means an international career is over. In his view, continuing to play would have allowed Shami to retain the possibility of earning another opportunity.

Mohammed Shami’s place among India’s leading Test fast bowlers

Shami leaves Test cricket with a record that places him among India’s most successful fast bowlers. His 229 wickets put him sixth on the list of India’s highest Test wicket-takers among fast bowlers, according to the figures provided.

Kapil Dev leads the group with 434 wickets, followed by Zaheer Khan and Ishant Sharma, who each collected 311. Javagal Srinath finished with 236, while Jasprit Bumrah has taken 234. Shami’s 229 wickets place him just behind those four names and Kapil.

His career was also affected by significant fitness setbacks. Heel and Achilles surgery in 2024, along with knee problems around the same period, kept him out of action for extended stretches. Those interruptions made his return to international cricket more challenging and contributed to the long gap since his last appearance for India.

Kapil Dev cites Bhuvneshwar Kumar’s international comeback

To explain why he believes Shami should have kept playing, Kapil pointed to Bhuvneshwar Kumar’s return to India’s T20I squad for the New Zealand tour in October. Bhuvneshwar received another international opportunity after spending almost four years away from the national team.

Kapil used the comeback as an example of how a player’s international career can remain open even after a lengthy absence. He argued that Shami could also have waited for another opportunity rather than retiring from the longest format.

“Bhuvneshwar Kumar can come out after four years, so why not? Yes, today I can understand they have so much other cricket to play, like T20 leagues, if they retire, but I think Test cricket is the best cricket,” said Kapil (via the aforementioned source).

Bhuvneshwar’s return, however, came with its own challenges. He played four of the five T20I matches against New Zealand and finished the series with one wicket for 180 runs in 16 overs. His economy rate was 11.25.

Although the numbers did not reflect a particularly successful series, his selection demonstrated that an extended absence does not necessarily prevent a player from returning to India’s international setup.

Shami and Bhuvneshwar take different paths

The contrast between the two fast bowlers forms the basis of Kapil’s argument. Bhuvneshwar remained available for selection and eventually received another opportunity after nearly four years away. Shami, meanwhile, chose to end his Test career despite continuing to play domestic cricket for Bengal.

Kapil’s comments suggest that Shami’s decision has closed the possibility of a Test comeback, regardless of what he might achieve in domestic cricket. Had he continued playing the format, he would at least have remained eligible for consideration if the selectors decided to bring him back.

That does not guarantee that Shami would have returned to the Indian team. His fitness, performances and the team’s selection requirements would still have played important roles. Nevertheless, Kapil believes that keeping the option open was worth considering, particularly given the experience and record Shami brought to the team.

What Kapil’s comments mean for Shami’s Test legacy

Shami’s retirement marks the end of a significant chapter in Indian Test cricket. His 229 wickets, six five-wicket hauls and consistent contributions with the ball established him as one of the country’s leading fast bowlers during his international career.

Kapil’s reaction highlights the debate surrounding the timing of the decision rather than questioning Shami’s achievements. The former captain believes the opportunity to represent India in Test cricket is too valuable to give up while a player still has the ability to compete.

For Shami, the decision brings his red-ball career to a close after years of international service and injury challenges. For Kapil, however, the example of Bhuvneshwar Kumar shows why players should consider keeping the door open for as long as possible.

Ultimately, Shami’s Test record remains intact, while Kapil’s remarks have brought fresh attention to the difficult choices experienced cricketers face when balancing fitness, playing opportunities and the future of their international careers.

FAQs

  • Why did Kapil Dev question Mohammed Shami's Test retirement?
  • When did Mohammed Shami announce his Test retirement?
  • How many Test wickets did Mohammed Shami take for India?
  • What were Mohammed Shami's best Test bowling figures?
  • Which cricketer did Kapil Dev cite as an example of an international comeback?
  • When did Mohammed Shami last play a Test match for India?
  • How many wickets did Kapil Dev take in Test cricket?
  • Does Mohammed Shami's retirement end his domestic cricket career?

For breaking news and live news updates, like us on Facebook or follow us on Twitter and Instagram. Read more on Latest Cricket on thefoxdaily.com.

COMMENTS 0