Delhi HC Clears ₹593-Crore Mauritius Fund Tax Exemption

Delhi High Court rules that ₹593.48 crore in mutual fund gains earned by Emerging India Focus Funds cannot be taxed in India under the Mauritius tax treaty.

Published: 8 hours ago

By Ashish kumar

Delhi HC Clears ₹593-Crore Mauritius Fund Tax Exemption
Delhi HC Clears ₹593-Crore Mauritius Fund Tax Exemption

The Delhi High Court has ruled in favour of Mauritius-based Emerging India Focus Funds in a significant tax dispute involving ₹593.48 crore in capital gains earned from the sale of equity mutual fund units. The court held that the gains cannot be taxed in India under the India-Mauritius Double Taxation Avoidance Agreement (DTAA), because mutual fund units are legally distinct from shares of the companies in which those funds invest.

The ruling came despite the fund declaring total taxable income of just ₹5,460 for the assessment year 2022-23 while claiming the entire ₹593.48 crore in capital gains as exempt from tax in India under the treaty. The Income Tax Department had challenged the exemption, arguing that the mutual fund units effectively represented investments in Indian company shares and should therefore attract Indian capital gains tax.

A division bench of Justices Subramonium Prasad and Renu Bhatnagar dismissed the department’s appeal, upholding the distinction between an investor holding mutual fund units and a shareholder directly owning equity in a company. The decision reinforces the importance of how different financial instruments are classified under international tax treaties.

Why the ₹593.48-Crore Capital Gains Dispute Reached the Delhi High Court

The dispute originated from Emerging India Focus Funds’ tax return for assessment year 2022-23. The Mauritius-based fund reported total income of ₹5,460 while disclosing capital gains of ₹593.48 crore from selling units of equity Mutual Funds.

The fund claimed that these gains were not taxable in India under the India-Mauritius DTAA. Its position was based on the argument that mutual fund units fall under a different category of assets from shares issued by Indian companies.

The Income Tax Department disagreed. It argued that equity mutual funds primarily invest in shares of Indian companies and that gains arising from the sale of their units should therefore be treated like gains from the sale of those underlying shares.

Under this interpretation, the department sought to bring the gains within Article 13(3A) of the India-Mauritius tax treaty, which allows India to tax certain gains from the sale of shares in Indian companies.

The disagreement was therefore not simply about the amount of income involved. It concerned a fundamental question of tax classification: should an investor selling units of an equity mutual fund be treated as selling shares, or as transferring a separate financial asset representing an interest in a mutual fund scheme?

How the Income Tax Department Challenged the Treaty Exemption

The assessing officer initially sought to tax ₹385.76 crore, representing 65% of the fund’s reported capital gains, under Article 13(3A) of the India-Mauritius DTAA.

The matter subsequently went before the Dispute Resolution Panel (DRP). The panel took a broader position and held that the entire ₹593.48 crore in capital gains should be taxable in India.

The fund challenged the tax treatment before the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT). In June 2025, the tribunal ruled in its favour, holding that mutual fund units and equity shares are distinct securities and should not automatically be treated as interchangeable for tax purposes.

The Income Tax Department then challenged the tribunal’s decision before the Delhi High Court. The High Court dismissed the appeal and upheld the distinction drawn by the ITAT.

Delhi High Court Explains Why Mutual Fund Units Are Not Equity Shares

The central reasoning behind the judgment is the legal relationship between a mutual fund investor and the companies whose shares form part of the fund’s portfolio.

When an investor purchases units of an equity mutual fund, the investor acquires an interest in the mutual fund scheme’s assets. The investor does not directly become a shareholder in every company in which the fund invests.

This distinction matters because ownership of a mutual fund unit does not automatically provide the same rights and liabilities as direct ownership of company shares. The mutual fund holds the underlying securities, while the unit holder owns units representing an interest in the scheme.

The bench observed that a mutual fund unit holder does not possess the rights and liabilities of a shareholder in the companies whose shares are held by the fund. It also noted that the treaty specifically addresses shares under Article 13(3A), while mutual fund units are not expressly included in that provision.

The court concluded that gains from the sale of the units could instead fall under Article 13(4), which deals with gains from assets not specifically covered by the preceding provisions of the treaty.

In its order, the court stated: “The unit holder does not have any rights and liabilities of the shareholder.”

The judgment makes the distinction between the underlying investments and the security actually sold central to determining which treaty provision applies.

Article 13(3A) vs Article 13(4): The Key India-Mauritius Tax Treaty Difference

The outcome of the case depended largely on how the two provisions of Article 13 of the India-Mauritius DTAA apply to different categories of assets.

Article 13(3A): Taxation of Gains From Shares

Article 13(3A) provides for taxation in India of certain capital gains arising from the sale of shares acquired on or after April 1, 2017, in Indian companies.

For example, if a Mauritius-based investor directly sells shares of an Indian company covered by this provision, India can exercise its taxing rights under the treaty. This provision was introduced to change the earlier treaty framework governing capital gains from Indian shares.

The Income Tax Department argued that equity mutual fund units should be treated similarly because their value is linked to investments in Indian company shares.

Article 13(4): Taxation of Gains From Other Assets

Article 13(4) covers capital gains from the sale of assets that are not specifically dealt with under the preceding provisions of the treaty. Under this provision, such gains are taxable only in the country where the seller is a tax resident.

Because Emerging India Focus Funds is based in Mauritius, the fund argued that its gains from selling mutual fund units fell within Article 13(4) and could therefore be taxed only in Mauritius.

The High Court accepted this interpretation. It held that the fund had sold mutual fund units rather than shares in the underlying Indian companies, making Article 13(4), rather than Article 13(3A), applicable to the transaction.

Why the Court Rejected the Tax Department’s Argument

The Income Tax Department sought a broader interpretation of the treaty, arguing that the economic substance of the investment should determine its tax treatment. Since equity mutual funds invest predominantly in shares, the department wanted the gains to be treated as gains from the sale of shares.

The High Court did not accept this approach. It emphasised that the treaty provisions must be interpreted according to the categories of assets specifically covered by the agreement between India and Mauritius.

The bench noted that the contracting countries had expressly referred to shares in Article 13(3A). The absence of the term ‘mutual fund’ from that provision was relevant to determining whether mutual fund units could be brought within its scope.

The court also referred to the Supreme Court’s judgment in Apollo Tyres Ltd v. CIT, which held that units of the Unit Trust of India cannot automatically be treated as shares.

By relying on this distinction, the High Court reinforced the principle that the legal character of the asset being transferred matters when applying tax treaty provisions. The fact that a mutual fund invests in shares does not, by itself, convert the units issued by that fund into direct equity shares.

The bench also observed that the intention of the contracting nations was to allocate taxing rights between the two countries for different categories of assets. It held that gains from the sale of property not covered by the specific share provision would be taxable in the country where the seller is resident.

Delhi High Court Dismisses Income Tax Department’s Appeal

After examining the treaty provisions and the distinction between mutual fund units and equity shares, the division bench upheld the ITAT’s decision in favour of Emerging India Focus Funds.

The court concluded that the capital gains from the sale of the mutual fund units fell under Article 13(4) of the India-Mauritius DTAA and were taxable only in Mauritius, rather than India.

The bench stated: “The question of law is answered in favour of the Assessee,” while dismissing the department’s appeal.

The ruling means that the Income Tax Department’s attempt to tax the ₹593.48 crore in gains in India was unsuccessful in this dispute. The judgment does not establish that every investment made through a Mauritius-based fund is automatically exempt from Indian tax. The treatment depends on the nature of the asset, the applicable treaty provisions and whether the relevant conditions for treaty benefits are satisfied.

What the Judgment Means for Foreign Portfolio Investors and Mutual Fund Investments

The decision is relevant to overseas investors and fund structures that invest in Indian markets through mutual fund units. It clarifies that the tax treatment of an investment cannot be determined solely by looking at the securities held within a fund’s portfolio.

For investors, the distinction between directly holding shares and holding units of a mutual fund can have significant tax consequences, particularly when investments involve cross-border structures and double taxation agreements.

The judgment also highlights the importance of the precise wording of international tax treaties. Different financial instruments may provide exposure to similar underlying assets but can receive different treatment because their legal ownership structures are not identical.

For the Income Tax Department, the ruling underscores the limits of treating different securities as equivalent merely because they derive value from the same underlying investments. A tax claim under a treaty must be supported by the specific provisions governing the asset that was actually transferred.

Does the Ruling Mean All Mauritius-Based Investors Can Avoid Capital Gains Tax in India?

No. The judgment concerns the specific capital gains earned by Emerging India Focus Funds from the sale of equity mutual fund units and the interpretation of the India-Mauritius DTAA applicable to those transactions.

It should not be interpreted as a blanket exemption for every Mauritius-based investor selling Indian financial assets. Direct transfers of shares, for example, can fall under Article 13(3A), which gives India taxing rights over qualifying transactions involving shares acquired on or after April 1, 2017.

The legal nature of the asset, the structure of the investment and the applicable treaty conditions remain important. Investors must also consider other relevant tax provisions and compliance requirements when assessing whether treaty benefits are available.

The immediate significance of the Delhi High Court ruling is narrower but important: equity mutual fund units cannot automatically be treated as shares in the underlying companies for the purpose of Article 13(3A). Where the units fall under Article 13(4), the treaty allocates the right to tax the gains to the seller’s country of residence.

Why the ₹593-Crore Case Matters for India’s International Tax Framework

The Emerging India Focus Funds dispute highlights how differences in the legal structure of financial products can shape cross-border taxation. An investment in an equity mutual fund may provide exposure to Indian company shares, but the investor’s immediate asset is the fund unit rather than the underlying shares themselves.

By upholding this distinction, the Delhi High Court has reinforced the need to apply tax treaties according to the assets and categories expressly covered by their provisions. The ruling also demonstrates why treaty interpretation can become decisive in disputes involving large capital gains, even when the underlying investments are connected to the same domestic securities market.

For foreign investors, fund managers and tax professionals, the decision offers important clarity on the treatment of mutual fund units under the India-Mauritius tax treaty. For the tax authorities, it establishes that economic exposure to shares and legal ownership of shares are not necessarily the same thing when determining the applicable treaty provision.

FAQs

  • What is the Emerging India Focus Funds tax case?
  • Why did Emerging India Focus Funds declare ₹593.48 crore as tax-exempt?
  • How much taxable income did Emerging India Focus Funds declare?
  • What did the Delhi High Court rule in the ₹593-crore tax case?
  • Why are mutual fund units different from equity shares?
  • What is the difference between Article 13(3A) and Article 13(4) of the India-Mauritius DTAA?
  • Can all Mauritius-based investors claim exemption from Indian capital gains tax after this ruling?
  • How could the Delhi High Court ruling affect foreign portfolio investors?

For breaking news and live news updates, like us on Facebook or follow us on Twitter and Instagram. Read more on Latest Business on thefoxdaily.com.

COMMENTS 0