
The Supreme Court has asked the Centre to incorporate measures for penalising violations of its restrictions on the unauthorised use of live-streamed judicial proceedings. The direction comes as the court examines concerns over courtroom videos being extracted, edited, circulated and monetised without permission.
According to news agency Press Trust of India (PTI), the court on Friday directed the government to include provisions for taking action against individuals and organisations that violate its interim orders in the proposed policy framework governing the live-streaming of court proceedings.
The court is considering petitions seeking safeguards against the unauthorised use of audio and video recordings of hearings, particularly when clips are altered, shared with misleading captions or used for commercial purposes.
Supreme Court asks Centre to include enforcement provisions
A bench comprising Chief Justice of India Surya Kant and Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V Mohana considered the matter after Solicitor General Tushar Mehta informed it that suggestions from various high courts and other stakeholders had been forwarded to the Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology.
The suggestions are intended to help the ministry prepare comprehensive guidelines for the use and distribution of recordings of judicial proceedings.
Mehta told the bench that the ministry would examine the suggestions and respond within a few days. He requested that the petitions be taken up for further consideration after the Diwali vacation.
The solicitor general also drew the court’s attention to alleged violations of its earlier restrictions. He urged the bench to consider directing the removal of material uploaded in breach of the existing orders.
Taking note of the submission, the bench made it clear that the proposed policy would also address enforcement. The court said:
“Necessary measures for taking action against those who fail to comply with the directions will also be incorporated in the policy regime.”
In its order, the bench referred to its earlier interim directions, including the order dated October 9, 2026. It stressed that the restrictions must be effectively implemented and followed.
Prashant Bhushan proposes digital signatures and watermarks
During the proceedings, advocate Prashant Bhushan suggested introducing a verification system for official recordings released by the Supreme Court.
He proposed that every official video clip published by the court should carry a verifiable digital signature or watermark. Such authentication would help viewers, news organisations and digital platforms distinguish genuine courtroom footage from manipulated or unauthorised versions.
Bhushan also suggested that recordings of all court proceedings should be made available on the Supreme Court’s official website in an authenticated and watermarked format.
The proposal is aimed at making verified courtroom footage easier to identify and reducing the possibility of misleading edits or altered recordings being circulated as authentic judicial content.
What are the Supreme Court’s restrictions on courtroom recordings?
The Supreme Court had introduced restrictions on the unauthorised use of audio and video recordings of judicial proceedings on July 24.
Under the directions, individuals and organisations were prohibited from extracting, circulating, monetising, posting, reposting, uploading, transmitting, modifying, storing or hosting recordings of court proceedings on social media or other digital platforms without prior permission.
Permission must be obtained from the Supreme Court secretary general or the registrar generals of the high courts concerned, depending on the court whose proceedings are being recorded.
The restrictions were intended to prevent unauthorised distribution and exploitation of courtroom recordings, including the circulation of edited clips that could misrepresent what happened during hearings.
Supreme Court clarifies restrictions do not ban news reporting
On September 18, the Supreme Court clarified the scope of its earlier directions, stating that they did not impose a blanket ban on recognised news organisations reporting judicial proceedings.
News outlets were allowed to continue covering court hearings, legal developments and judicial decisions. However, they could not use audio or video clips of hearings in their reports under the restrictions then in force.
The clarification distinguished between legitimate journalistic reporting and the unauthorised use of recordings. The court’s directions were not intended to prevent the media from informing the public about court proceedings.
October 9 order raised concerns over commercial exploitation
On October 9, the bench reiterated that there was no question of gagging news reporting or restricting the live-streaming of court proceedings.
However, the court expressed serious concern about the commercial exploitation of courtroom recordings through monetisation, advertisements, personal promotion and misleading representations.
The Chief Justice of India observed that the misuse of live-streamed proceedings for commercial gain had caused immense damage to the Bar, the Bench and the institution as a whole.
Justice Joymalya Bagchi also raised concerns about lawyers using courtroom recordings for personal promotion and professional benefit. He indicated that such practices raised questions about the principles and standards governing the legal profession.
The observations reflect the court’s concern that recordings intended to improve transparency and public access to judicial proceedings could be used in ways that distort their purpose or create misleading impressions.
Why the proposed live-streaming policy matters
Live-streaming allows members of the public to follow judicial proceedings and observe how courts hear arguments and consider legal questions. However, the unauthorised extraction and circulation of recordings can create risks when short clips are separated from their original context or edited to suggest something different from what occurred during a hearing.
Commercial use can raise additional concerns when courtroom footage is monetised, accompanied by advertisements or used to promote individuals without permission.
The Supreme Court’s latest direction seeks to ensure that the Centre’s proposed policy does not focus only on regulating access to recordings but also establishes measures to address violations.
Suggestions such as digital signatures and watermarks could also help identify authentic footage, although the court has not yet announced whether these proposals will form part of the final framework.
What happens next?
The Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology will examine suggestions received from high courts and other stakeholders while preparing the proposed guidelines. Solicitor General Tushar Mehta told the Supreme Court that the ministry would respond within a few days.
The Centre’s policy is expected to include measures for taking action against those who violate restrictions on the unauthorised extraction, circulation and commercial use of courtroom recordings.
The Supreme Court will continue hearing the petitions after the Diwali vacation. Until then, its existing interim restrictions remain relevant, including the distinction between permissible news reporting and the unauthorised use of audio and video recordings of judicial proceedings.
For breaking news and live news updates, like us on Facebook or follow us on Twitter and Instagram. Read more on Latest India on thefoxdaily.com.

COMMENTS 0