
The Allahabad High Court has questioned the Uttar Pradesh government over the continued registration of criminal cases under the Uttar Pradesh Gangsters and Anti-Social Activities (Prevention) Act, 1986, despite the Supreme Court having declared the law “stillborn” in an August 2026 judgment. The court has sought a personal explanation from the state’s Additional Chief Secretary for Home and demanded details of action against officials responsible for registering cases under the Act.
The intervention follows a petition challenging an FIR registered in Ambedkar Nagar district under Section 3(1) of the legislation. The Lucknow Bench has stayed the FIR and directed that no further proceedings take place in the matter until further orders. It has also asked the state government to explain why police authorities continued invoking the law after the Supreme Court’s ruling.
The case raises serious questions about compliance with binding judicial decisions, the accountability of police and administrative officials, and the legal consequences for people booked under a statute that the country’s highest court has declared invalid in the context of the judgment.
Why Has the Allahabad High Court Questioned UP Police?
A division bench of Justices Abdul Moin and Pramod Kumar took up the matter on Friday after hearing a petition filed by Brijesh Kumar, also known as Banty Verma. The petitioner challenged an FIR registered against him on October 23 at Akbarpur police station in Ambedkar Nagar district under Section 3(1) of the Uttar Pradesh Gangsters and Anti-Social Activities (Prevention) Act, 1986.
During the hearing, the court was informed that the Supreme Court had already delivered a judgment concerning the legislation in August 2026. In the case of Shiv Pratap Singh alias Chinu versus State of Uttar Pradesh and Others, the apex court had declared the Act “stillborn”. The petitioner argued that police authorities could not continue registering cases under a law after that ruling.
The High Court questioned why the state authorities had not stopped using the Act despite the Supreme Court’s decision. It observed that once the legal position had been settled by the apex court, there could be no justification for continuing to register FIRs under the legislation.
The bench made clear that government authorities were expected to comply with the Supreme Court’s ruling rather than continue proceedings that could be legally unsustainable. The court’s concern extended beyond the individual petition, as the continued registration of such FIRs could affect other people facing criminal proceedings under the same law.
Additional Chief Secretary for Home Asked to File Personal Affidavit
Seeking accountability at the administrative level, the Allahabad High Court directed the Additional Chief Secretary for Home in Uttar Pradesh to submit a personal affidavit within three weeks.
The affidavit must explain why FIRs continued to be registered under the 1986 Gangsters Act after the Supreme Court’s August 2026 judgment. The state government has also been asked to disclose what action is proposed against officials responsible for registering cases under the legislation.
The court wants the government to provide details of corrective measures being taken to prevent similar cases from being registered in the future. This requirement indicates that the bench is examining not only the legality of the petitioner’s FIR but also the administrative failure that may have allowed the practice to continue.
The direction carries a clear warning. If the required affidavit is not filed within the prescribed period, the Additional Chief Secretary for Home will have to appear personally before the court along with the relevant records.
The matter has been listed for December 15, when the bench is expected to examine the government’s response and consider the next steps.
High Court Stays FIR Against Brijesh Kumar
The immediate legal relief in the case has gone to Brijesh Kumar, who had approached the High Court challenging the FIR registered against him at Akbarpur police station.
The case was registered on October 23 under Section 3(1) of the Uttar Pradesh Gangsters and Anti-Social Activities (Prevention) Act. Kumar argued that the proceedings could not lawfully continue because the Supreme Court had already declared the legislation “stillborn” in its August 2026 judgment.
After considering the submissions, the Lucknow Bench stayed the FIR and ordered that no further proceedings be taken in the case until further orders. The interim protection prevents the authorities from continuing the challenged proceedings while the High Court examines the legal and administrative issues raised in the petition.
The order is significant because the court has connected the petitioner’s individual grievance with a broader question about whether police authorities have been following the Supreme Court’s ruling. The bench’s demand for a government affidavit suggests that it wants a clear account of how the FIR came to be registered and whether similar cases have continued across the state.
What Does ‘Stillborn’ Mean in the Gangsters Act Case?
The term “stillborn” has particular legal significance in this dispute. In the context of the Supreme Court’s judgment, it indicates that the legislation was treated as having no valid legal force under the legal position established by the court.
Once the Supreme Court has settled a question of law, authorities and subordinate courts are required to follow that interpretation. Police departments cannot simply continue applying a provision as though the judgment had not been delivered.
The High Court’s concern is that the registration of fresh FIRs under the Act after the apex court’s ruling could expose individuals to proceedings based on a legal framework that has already been rejected by the Supreme Court.
However, the precise scope and legal consequences of the August 2026 judgment must be understood from the Supreme Court’s actual ruling. The present High Court proceedings are focused on the continued registration of FIRs and the state’s responsibility to explain why its authorities allegedly failed to act in accordance with that decision.
High Court Says Authorities Were Already Warned
One of the more serious aspects of the proceedings is the High Court’s observation that the continued registration of FIRs under the Act was not an issue that had gone unnoticed within the government legal system.
The bench noted that additional government advocates had previously brought the matter to the attention of the authorities. Despite those warnings, the registration of cases under the legislation apparently continued.
This has raised questions about whether the problem resulted from a lack of communication, inadequate instructions to police stations, administrative negligence or a failure to implement the Supreme Court’s decision at the ground level.
The court expressed concern that litigants were being forced to approach the High Court to challenge actions that should not have continued after the Supreme Court clarified the legal position.
It also said that it should not repeatedly have to point out the authorities’ failure to comply with judgments delivered by the apex court. The bench described the resulting burden on the constitutional court as a waste of its “precious judicial time”.
The observation reflects a broader institutional concern: when government departments fail to implement binding judicial decisions, affected individuals may have little choice but to seek fresh court intervention. This creates additional litigation and places avoidable pressure on an already burdened judicial system.
What Is the Uttar Pradesh Gangsters and Anti-Social Activities Act?
The Uttar Pradesh Gangsters and Anti-Social Activities (Prevention) Act, 1986, was enacted to address organised criminal activity and the operations of gangs in the state. It provides a legal framework for taking action against individuals alleged to be involved in organised criminal conduct.
Section 3 of the Act deals with punishment for gangster-related activities. It has been used by law enforcement authorities in cases involving alleged organised criminal networks and activities considered harmful to public order and security.
The legislation has been an important part of Uttar Pradesh’s criminal enforcement framework for decades. However, its continued application depends on its legal validity and compliance with constitutional and judicial requirements.
The present dispute is particularly significant because it concerns the use of the Act after the Supreme Court’s August 2026 ruling. The High Court is now seeking to establish why the police continued registering FIRs under its provisions and what steps the state has taken to prevent further use of the legislation.
Could Officials Face Action for Registering FIRs?
The Allahabad High Court has specifically asked the state government to disclose the action proposed against officials responsible for registering cases under the Act after the Supreme Court’s judgment.
This could bring the conduct of police personnel and other officials under scrutiny. If the government finds that officers continued registering FIRs despite clear instructions or knowledge of the Supreme Court’s ruling, it may have to consider appropriate administrative or disciplinary measures, depending on the facts and applicable service rules.
However, the High Court has not yet announced any punishment or disciplinary action against specific officials. It has asked the government to explain what action is proposed and provide details of measures intended to prevent a recurrence.
The court’s demand for corrective steps is also important for people who may have been booked under the same provisions. A clear government response could help establish whether other FIRs require review and how police stations will be instructed to follow the Supreme Court’s decision.
What Happens Next in the Case?
The Uttar Pradesh government has been given three weeks to submit the personal affidavit of the Additional Chief Secretary for Home. The affidavit must address the continued registration of FIRs under the Gangsters Act, explain the authorities’ conduct and outline the action proposed against officials concerned.
The next hearing is scheduled for December 15. If the affidavit is not submitted, the senior official may be required to appear personally before the bench with the relevant records.
The High Court’s eventual response will depend on the explanation provided by the state government and the material placed before it. The proceedings could also clarify what administrative safeguards are necessary to ensure that police authorities do not continue registering cases under a law declared “stillborn” by the Supreme Court.
For now, the FIR against Brijesh Kumar remains stayed, with no further proceedings permitted in that case until further orders. The larger issue, however, extends beyond one petitioner: the court is demanding accountability from the Uttar Pradesh administration over its compliance with the country’s highest judicial authority.
The December 15 hearing will therefore be important not only for the petitioner but also for determining how the state government intends to address the alleged failure to implement the Supreme Court’s ruling across its police and administrative machinery.
For breaking news and live news updates, like us on Facebook or follow us on Twitter and Instagram. Read more on Latest India on thefoxdaily.com.

COMMENTS 0