
The Supreme Court on Wednesday issued notices to the Centre, Delhi government and several political parties and organisations over a petition filed by Delhi traders’ associations challenging the designation of Ramlila Maidan as an authorised protest site. The petitioners have argued that demonstrations at the ground affect commercial activity, disrupt traffic and create difficulties for people living and working in surrounding neighbourhoods.
A bench headed by Chief Justice of India Surya Kant, also comprising Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V Mohana, sought responses from the concerned parties and agreed to hear the matter after two weeks.
The case places two sets of public interests before the court: the right of citizens and organisations to hold peaceful demonstrations, and the rights of traders, workers and residents to carry on their daily activities without unreasonable disruption.
Which Parties and Organisations Have Received Supreme Court Notices?
The Supreme Court has sought responses from the following parties and organisations:
- The Union government
- The Delhi government
- The Indian National Congress
- The Aam Aadmi Party (AAP)
- The Cockroach Janta Party (CJP)
- The All India Students Association (AISA)
The notices follow changes to the list of respondents in the traders’ petition. The court had earlier questioned whether the organisations responsible for calling demonstrations had been made parties to the proceedings.
On November 3, the bench asked the petitioners to include the relevant political parties and organisations. The Congress was added because it had organised a rally at Ramlila Maidan on November 1. The AAP, CJP and AISA were also subsequently included.
The court agreed that the organisations involved in organising demonstrations should have an opportunity to respond before the dispute is considered further.
Why Are Delhi Traders Challenging Ramlila Maidan as a Protest Venue?
The petition was filed by the Kirana Committee of Delhi and the Delhi Iron and Hardware Merchants Association of Chawri Bazar. The traders have challenged the Delhi Police order dated October 11 designating Ramlila Maidan as a protest site.
They argue that the ground is surrounded by residential neighbourhoods and major wholesale and retail markets in Old Delhi. These include Connaught Place, Chandni Chowk, Chawri Bazar, Khari Baoli and Sadar Bazar.
According to the petitioners, demonstrations at the venue can affect access to these commercial areas, making it harder for customers, suppliers, employees and transport operators to carry out their work.
Senior advocate Mukul Rohatgi, appearing for the traders, told the Supreme Court that the location was unsuitable because of its proximity to prominent markets.
“I am also challenging the notification of Ramlila Maidan as a protest site is also wrong. This location is within close proximity of prominent markets such as Connaught Place, Chandni Chowk, Chawri Bazar, Khari Baoli and Sadar Bazar,” Rohatgi submitted.
The traders contend that the decision to designate the ground was made without a publicly available assessment of its impact on surrounding businesses and residential areas.
Centre Says Protest Rights and Traders’ Rights Should Be Heard Together
Solicitor General Tushar Mehta, representing the Centre, told the court that the petition should be considered alongside other cases concerning police action during protests in Delhi.
He argued that the proceedings involve competing fundamental rights and should be examined together rather than in isolation.
“This court is hearing the other set of petitions seeking their right to protest. And this matter is protesting that right citing the fundamental rights of traders, workers, and residents. These are contesting rights and should be heard together,” Mehta said.
The submission highlights the central legal question in the dispute: how authorities should balance the right to peaceful assembly with the interests of people whose livelihoods, movement and access to essential services may be affected by demonstrations.
The Supreme Court had also observed during an earlier hearing that protests can affect people working in shops and those earning their livelihood by selling goods from carts and stalls.
₹250 Crore in Daily Business Allegedly at Risk During Peak Season
The traders’ petition argues that demonstrations at Ramlila Maidan can have a particularly significant economic impact during the festive and peak trading season.
According to the petition, Delhi records daily business activity worth approximately ₹500 crore to ₹600 crore. It estimates that around ₹250 crore could be at risk each day during the peak period between October 2026 and January 2027 if commercial activity is disrupted.
The petition also states that nearly one million business establishments, around 10 million livelihoods and approximately 500,000 traders from outside Delhi depend on the city’s commercial activity.
These figures represent estimates presented by the petitioners and are not findings made by the Supreme Court.
The traders say the impact of disrupted market access extends beyond shop owners. Employees, daily-wage workers, street vendors, hawkers, delivery personnel, drivers and artisans could also face losses when customers and goods cannot move freely through affected areas.
The petitioners have argued that the timing of demonstrations is especially important because many traders earn a substantial portion of their annual income during the festive months and the period leading into the new year.
Dispute Began With Closure of Central Park in Connaught Place
The traders initially approached the court over an order issued by the New Delhi Municipal Council (NDMC) to close Central Park in Connaught Place for a proposed march called “Lehra Do Tiranga”, organised by the CJP with participation from AISA on October 16.
The petition was filed on October 16, with the traders challenging the arrangements for the proposed demonstration and the use of public spaces near commercial areas.
The subsequent Congress rally at Ramlila Maidan on November 1 strengthened the petitioners’ concerns about the suitability of the ground as a designated protest venue.
The traders argue that the issue is not limited to one march or one political organisation. Their petition challenges the broader decision to designate Ramlila Maidan as a protest site without what they consider adequate consideration of its surroundings and the people affected.
What Do the Traders Want From the Supreme Court?
The petitioners have asked the Supreme Court to quash the Delhi Police order dated October 11 that designated Ramlila Maidan as a protest venue. They have also sought a fresh and reasoned assessment of the location, taking into account the interests of traders, workers and residents.
They have clarified that they are not seeking a blanket ban on peaceful protests. Instead, they want a clear framework governing how demonstrations are organised and managed in areas close to major markets and residential neighbourhoods.
The safeguards sought by the traders include:
- Clear rules governing the location, duration and scale of demonstrations.
- Traffic arrangements that allow access to commercial and residential areas.
- Continued access to markets, hospitals and public transport.
- Preventive planning to minimise disruption to businesses and local communities.
- Appropriate enforcement of the law in cases involving violence or vandalism.
- Accountability for damage to public or private property without treating peaceful demonstrators as responsible for unlawful acts committed by others.
The petitioners argue that a structured system would allow political organisations to exercise their right to protest while reducing the impact on people who depend on nearby markets and public infrastructure.
Supreme Court to Examine Competing Rights in Delhi Protest Venue Case
The Supreme Court’s decision to seek responses from political parties, organisations and government authorities brings the dispute into a wider legal examination of protest management in the national capital.
The case does not concern only whether demonstrations should be permitted at Ramlila Maidan. It also raises questions about how authorities assess the suitability of protest locations, regulate the size and duration of gatherings, manage traffic and protect access to essential services.
The right to peaceful assembly is an important democratic freedom. At the same time, traders and residents have raised concerns about the consequences of prolonged or poorly managed demonstrations in densely populated commercial areas.
The responses from the Centre, Delhi government and the organisations named in the petition will help the court examine the competing claims. The matter is expected to come up again after two weeks, when the Supreme Court will consider the next steps in the proceedings.
For breaking news and live news updates, like us on Facebook or follow us on Twitter and Instagram. Read more on Latest India on thefoxdaily.com.

COMMENTS 0