Congress Questions SIR After 1,600 Suspected Foreign Nationals Detected

Congress questions the SIR after around 1,600 suspected foreign nationals were identified across six states, while the Election Commission defends the exercise's legal basis.

Published: October 29, 2026

By Ashish kumar

Congress Questions SIR After 1,600 Suspected Foreign Nationals Detected
Congress Questions SIR After 1,600 Suspected Foreign Nationals Detected

The Congress has intensified its criticism of the Election Commission of India’s Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls, alleging that the exercise is being used to remove large numbers of eligible Indian voters rather than primarily identify foreign nationals. The Opposition party has demanded the removal of Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar, suspension of the revision process and changes to the ECINET portal.

The latest criticism followed a claim shared by Congress general secretary in charge of communications Jairam Ramesh that around 1,600 suspected foreign nationals had been identified across six states where the SIR had either been completed or was under way. According to Ramesh, nearly 10 crore people had undergone the revision process in those states.

The figures have become a focal point in the political dispute over the purpose, implementation and consequences of the electoral-roll revision. While the Congress has questioned whether the scale of the exercise is justified by the reported number of foreign nationals identified, the Election Commission has maintained that the SIR is authorised by law and that its decisions follow established procedures.

Congress Questions the Outcome of the SIR Exercise

On Thursday, the Congress alleged that the SIR was a conspiracy designed by Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Union Home Minister Amit Shah and implemented by Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar. The party claimed that the exercise could deprive large sections of Indian citizens of their constitutional right to vote, according to news agency Press Trust of India.

Ramesh raised questions about the results of the revision in a post on X, sharing a media report that said at least 1,600 suspected foreign nationals had been detected in Karnataka, Jharkhand, Meghalaya, Kerala, Goa and Mizoram.

He contrasted the reported figure with the approximately 10 crore people who had gone through the SIR process across the six states. According to the Congress leader, the numbers raised questions about whether the exercise was proportionate to its stated objective of identifying foreign nationals on electoral rolls.

Ramesh referred to the Home Minister’s description of the SIR as an exercise with a three-part objective: detect, delete and deport alleged infiltrators to purify electoral rolls. He questioned what the process had achieved in practical terms, given the number of suspected foreign nationals reportedly identified.

The Congress’s argument centres on the distinction between identifying people who may be ineligible to vote and ensuring that eligible Indian citizens are not wrongly removed from electoral rolls. The party alleges that the SIR risks affecting legitimate voters on a much larger scale than the reported number of suspected foreign nationals suggests.

However, the figures cited by Ramesh alone do not establish how many people were wrongly removed from electoral rolls or how many deletions were linked specifically to the identification of foreign nationals. The reported numbers and the Congress’s interpretation of them remain separate issues in the wider dispute.

Six States and the Reported Detection of 1,600 Foreign Nationals

According to the figures cited by Ramesh, Karnataka, Jharkhand, Meghalaya, Kerala, Goa and Mizoram together reported the identification of approximately 1,600 foreign nationals during the SIR process. He said nearly 10 crore people had been covered by the revision in these states.

The Congress leader also questioned why comparable figures had not been provided for the other 20 states and Union Territories. He claimed that the Election Commission had not asked those jurisdictions to collect and report the same data.

The absence of comparable figures, as described by Ramesh, has become part of the party’s criticism of the transparency surrounding the exercise. Without consistent information across jurisdictions, it is difficult to make a direct comparison of the number of suspected foreign nationals identified in different parts of the country.

The figures cited in the political debate should also be understood within their stated scope. They concern six states where the revision had been completed or was under way, rather than a consolidated nationwide total covering every state and Union Territory.

The reported figure of 1,600 does not, by itself, provide a complete picture of the SIR’s overall results. A fuller assessment would require comparable data on the number of people covered, the reasons for additions and deletions, the cases involving suspected foreign nationals and the outcomes of any subsequent verification or review.

Karnataka Figures Become a Key Point in the Debate

Karnataka has featured prominently in the Congress’s argument. Ramesh said that 99.7 lakh names had been deleted in the state and that 716 foreign nationals had been identified, according to PTI.

He further stated that 545 of the identified foreign nationals were from Nepal. The figures were cited to support the Congress’s contention that the number of people identified as foreign nationals was small compared with the total number of names removed from the electoral rolls.

These figures have sharpened the political debate over the relationship between voter deletions and the identification of people who may not be eligible to vote. The Congress argues that the scale of the deletions warrants scrutiny, particularly when compared with the number of foreign nationals reportedly detected.

Nevertheless, the two categories should not automatically be treated as equivalent. The total number of deleted names may include cases involving reasons other than suspected foreign nationality, while the figure cited for foreign nationals represents a separate category. The available figures in the supplied report do not provide a complete breakdown of every deletion or establish that all deleted names were connected to the same grounds.

That distinction is central to evaluating the competing claims. The number of suspected foreign nationals identified may be relevant to assessing one stated objective of the SIR, but it does not independently establish whether other changes to the electoral rolls were justified or whether eligible voters were incorrectly excluded.

Congress Renews Demands for Gyanesh Kumar’s Removal

Following his criticism of the reported figures, Ramesh repeated three demands on behalf of the Congress: the removal of Gyanesh Kumar as Chief Election Commissioner, suspension of the SIR and an overhaul of the ECINET portal.

The party has argued that the process threatens the voting rights of eligible citizens and that the Election Commission’s handling of the revision requires greater scrutiny. Its criticism has extended beyond the number of suspected foreign nationals identified to questions about the technology and institutional procedures involved in electoral-roll management.

The demand for Kumar’s removal reflects the Congress’s direct criticism of the leadership overseeing the exercise. By calling for the SIR to be suspended, the party has also challenged the continuation of the revision process itself rather than limiting its objections to individual deletions or specific state-level figures.

The proposed overhaul of ECINET forms another part of the dispute. Ramesh alleged that the portal was among the means through which the SIR was being implemented. The Congress has called for changes, although the supplied account does not detail the specific technical modifications the party wants or establish that the portal itself caused any particular voter deletion.

The Election Commission has rejected the broader allegations against the process, maintaining that its decisions have legal backing and were taken according to established procedures. The disagreement therefore extends to both the practical effects of the SIR and the institutional legitimacy of the decisions made by the poll body.

Election Commission Defends the SIR Before the Supreme Court

The latest Congress remarks came amid an ongoing legal and political dispute over the SIR. On Tuesday, the party described the Election Commission’s affidavit before the Supreme Court as “deceptive, deceitful and duplicitous”, arguing that the submission was damaging to the institution itself.

Ramesh also used a literary reference to criticise the commission’s position, suggesting that inconsistencies in its explanations would eventually become apparent. His comments followed the Election Commission’s detailed defence of the revision process before the court.

In its response, the Election Commission maintained that the SIR was authorised by law. It also said that the relevant orders had been approved unanimously by all three members of the commission.

The commission’s position challenges the Congress’s allegations about the legitimacy of the exercise. While the party has questioned the purpose and consequences of the revision, the poll body has argued that the process rests on statutory authority and established institutional procedures.

The legal dispute is significant because the controversy involves more than competing political statements. Questions about the authority to revise electoral rolls, the procedures used to verify voter eligibility and the safeguards available to people affected by deletions can have direct implications for electoral administration.

The supplied account does not establish that the Supreme Court has accepted either side’s interpretation of the disputed issues. The commission’s affidavit represents its defence of the process, while the Congress’s objections reflect the party’s challenge to that defence.

ECI Rejects Allegations of Changes to Form 6

Another point of contention concerns Form 6, the statutory form used for voter registration. In its 248-page response to a petition challenging the Chief Election Commissioner and the commission’s decisions, the Election Commission rejected allegations that the form had been amended.

The commission said no changes had been made to the statutory form. This response addressed a specific allegation connected to the broader controversy over the revision of electoral rolls and the procedures governing voter registration.

The issue matters because forms and documentation are part of the administrative process through which eligible voters enter electoral rolls. Claims about changes to those procedures can raise questions about the consistency of registration requirements and the way applications are handled.

However, the commission’s denial and the Congress’s wider objections need to be considered separately. The rejection of the claim about Form 6 does not, by itself, resolve every dispute over voter deletions, the SIR’s implementation or the operation of ECINET. Similarly, the Congress’s allegations do not establish that the form was changed or that the commission acted unlawfully.

The competing positions underline the need to distinguish specific procedural claims from broader political accusations. Each allegation requires evidence relating to the particular action or decision being questioned.

Reported Objections by Two Election Commissioners Add to the Controversy

The dispute intensified after The Indian Express reported that Election Commissioners Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi had recorded objections at least 14 times over the preceding 10 months to decisions and orders, most of them concerning the SIR process.

The report brought additional attention to internal deliberations within the Election Commission and prompted further questions about how decisions relating to the revision had been reached.

The Election Commission responded that differing views and observations were a normal part of deliberations within an institution. It maintained that the orders in question had full legal sanction and had been issued in accordance with established procedures.

The reported objections do not, on their own, establish that the commission’s decisions were unlawful or that the SIR was designed to remove eligible voters. They do, however, form part of the wider public discussion about the decision-making process and the degree of scrutiny applied to major electoral-administration measures.

Institutional disagreements can occur even when an organisation ultimately adopts a formal decision. The significance of the reported objections depends on the substance of the concerns raised, the decisions to which they related and the legal and procedural basis of the final orders. Those details are not fully set out in the supplied account.

The commission’s response has focused on the legitimacy of its decisions and the role of differing opinions in institutional deliberations. The Congress, meanwhile, has continued to use the reported disagreements as part of its criticism of the SIR and the poll body’s handling of the exercise.

Why the SIR Dispute Matters for Voter Rights

The Special Intensive Revision has become a major point of contention because electoral rolls determine who is registered to vote. Any large-scale revision therefore raises questions about both the accuracy of the rolls and the protection of eligible citizens from wrongful exclusion.

Updating electoral rolls can involve reviewing existing entries, identifying records that require correction and determining whether individuals meet the relevant eligibility requirements. At the same time, procedures must allow eligible voters to establish their status and address errors that could affect their registration.

The Congress argues that the scale of the SIR and the reported number of suspected foreign nationals identified point to a mismatch between the exercise’s stated objectives and its effects. The party has used the reported figures from six states to challenge the justification for the process and to demand its suspension.

The Election Commission’s position is that the revision is legally authorised and follows established procedures. Its defence places emphasis on the statutory basis of the exercise and the formal decisions through which it has been implemented.

Determining the practical impact of the SIR requires more than comparing one reported category with the total number of deletions. Relevant information would include the reasons names were removed, the number of people who sought corrections or restoration, the outcomes of verification procedures and consistent state-by-state figures.

Transparent and comparable data would help clarify the extent to which the revision has identified ineligible entries, corrected records and affected eligible voters. Such information would also make it easier to assess claims about the exercise’s purpose without relying solely on political statements.

What Happens Next?

The immediate dispute remains centred on the Congress’s demands for Kumar’s removal, suspension of the SIR and changes to ECINET. The party has linked those demands to its allegations about voter deletions, the reported detection of foreign nationals and the commission’s internal decision-making.

The Election Commission, for its part, has defended the legal authority behind the revision, rejected the allegation that Form 6 was amended and maintained that its orders were adopted through established procedures. It has also argued that differences of opinion among commissioners are part of institutional deliberations and do not invalidate the resulting decisions.

The Supreme Court proceedings form an important part of the wider dispute, although the supplied information does not establish a final judicial determination on the contested allegations. The commission’s affidavit and the Congress’s criticism represent opposing positions in an ongoing debate over electoral administration.

Further clarity will depend on the details of the revision, the availability of comparable data across states and any legal developments addressing the questions raised. In particular, a fuller breakdown of voter deletions and the grounds for those decisions would help distinguish the identification of suspected foreign nationals from other changes to electoral rolls.

Conclusion

The Congress’s latest criticism of the Special Intensive Revision centres on its claim that approximately 1,600 suspected foreign nationals were identified across six states after nearly 10 crore people underwent the process. Jairam Ramesh has argued that the figures raise questions about the exercise’s stated objective and has renewed demands for the removal of Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar, suspension of the SIR and an overhaul of ECINET.

The Election Commission has rejected the broader challenge to its actions, maintaining that the revision is authorised by law and that its orders follow established procedures. It has also denied that Form 6 was amended and defended the role of internal deliberations in reaching institutional decisions.

The reported figures have become central to the political argument, but they do not alone establish the reasons behind all voter deletions or determine whether eligible citizens were wrongly excluded. A clearer assessment will require detailed, comparable information on the outcomes of the revision, alongside consideration of the legal questions raised before the Supreme Court.

FAQs

  • What is the Special Intensive Revision (SIR)?
  • Why is the Congress criticising the SIR?
  • How many suspected foreign nationals were reportedly identified during the SIR?
  • What figures did Jairam Ramesh cite for Karnataka?
  • What demands has the Congress made over the SIR?
  • How has the Election Commission responded to the allegations?
  • Did the Election Commission change Form 6 for voter registration?
  • Does the reported figure of 1,600 prove that eligible voters were wrongly removed?

For breaking news and live news updates, like us on Facebook or follow us on Twitter and Instagram. Read more on Latest India on thefoxdaily.com.

COMMENTS 0